If you’re trying to change a behaviour and it’s not sticking, it doesn’t necessarily mean you’re unmotivated or doing it wrong. Often it means you’re using a strategy that doesn’t fit where you actually are in the change process.
We tend to think of change as a decision followed by action. Decide to change, then just do it. In reality, behaviour change is more like a cycle. We move through different stages, sometimes forwards and sometimes back, and each stage needs something different from us.
When we skip this step, working out where we are in the cycle, we can end up pushing for action before we are ready or feeling discouraged when trying harder does not work.
Not quite there yet
Precontemplation
At this stage, change is not really on your radar. Or you might know something is not working, but you are not ready to do anything about it. This often gets labelled as denial or avoidance, but it is usually protective. The behaviour is doing something for you.
What helps here is noticing patterns without forcing change. Gentle curiosity works better than pressure. Paying attention to both the benefits and the costs of the behaviour can be enough to start movement.
Thinking about it
Contemplation
You are weighing it up. Part of you wants to change and part of you really does not. This is where many people get stuck, not because they lack motivation, but because both sides make sense.
What helps here is clarity rather than action. Understanding why you might want to change and what you are worried you would lose is more useful than setting rules or goals too early.
Getting ready
Preparation
You have decided something needs to shift, but you are still working out how. This stage is about planning, choosing a starting point, and being honest about barriers and capacity.
What helps here is keeping plans small and specific. Not “I’ll exercise more,” but “I’ll walk for ten minutes after dinner three nights this week.” Over ambitious plans tend to collapse quickly.
Doing the thing
Action
This is the visible part of change. The new behaviour itself. It often looks like the hardest stage, but it is usually the shortest.
What helps here is support and flexibility. Expecting change to feel natural straight away is a fast way to give up. New behaviours feel effortful before they feel normal.
Keeping it going
Maintenance
This is where many change attempts quietly fall apart. Not because the behaviour stopped working, but because life happened. Stress, illness, holidays, or simply fatigue.
What helps here is planning for slips rather than treating them as failure. Maintenance is not about perfection. It is about returning without self punishment.
Why this matters at New Year
New Year energy tends to push us straight into action. Goals, rules, resets. This works well if you are already in the preparation or action stage. If you are not, it often leads to frustration and a familiar sense of “here we go again.”
A more sustainable approach is to ask:
- Where am I in the cycle right now?
- What would actually help at this stage?
- What is one small step that fits my current capacity?
Change does not have to be dramatic to be meaningful. When the strategy matches the stage, it is steadier, kinder, and far more likely to last beyond January.
You can download my Stages of Change handout to help you identify where you are in the cycle and what kinds of strategies are most useful at each stage.
If you would like support applying this to your own situation, you are welcome to book an appointment to meet with me. You can get in touch via the Contact page on the Arrive Psychology website.
